HSBC loses Brooklyn foreclosure action over six year time limit
A New York appeals court dismissed a foreclosure lawsuit by HSBC Bank USA after a five year delay in adding a necessary party breached the statute of limitations.
FTMQ Real Estate, written by our newsroom1 view

A New York appeals court dismissed an amended foreclosure complaint brought by HSBC Bank USA against a subsequent property owner in Brooklyn. MPA Magazine and Mortgage Professional America reported that the Appellate Division, Second Department, reversed a lower court decision on November 12. The appellate panel ruled that the six year statute of limitations governing mortgage foreclosure actions in New York had already expired when HSBC moved to add the property owner to the case. [1][2]
The timeline of the legal action caused the dismissal of the lawsuit. MPA Magazine reported that HSBC originally filed its foreclosure action in February 2015 against the borrower on the mortgage for the Brooklyn property. The borrower did not file an answer or appear in the court proceedings, leading the court to grant an order of reference. [1]
HSBC subsequently experienced a five year delay before moving to bring the new property owner into the case as a necessary party. MPA Magazine reported that this procedural delay pushed the filing of the bank's amended complaint beyond the legally permitted six year window, forcing the appellate court to dismiss the case on timing rather than on legal merits. [1]
Strict adherence to statute of limitations timelines remains a core issue in local property disputes. As FTMQ Real Estate reported earlier, the Appellate Division previously rejected a corporate buyer's motion to intervene in a Brooklyn foreclosure case after the entity waited 14 years, from August 2008 to August 2022, to challenge a judgment. [5]
In short
- The New York Appellate Division, Second Department, dismissed HSBC's foreclosure complaint on November 12.
- HSBC filed the original foreclosure lawsuit against the Brooklyn borrower in February 2015.
- The bank waited five years to add a subsequent property owner as a necessary party.
- New York law enforces a six-year statute of limitations on mortgage foreclosure actions.
Sources
Every paragraph above points to the numbered items it rests on. Read the originals here.
- [1]HSBC runs out the clock on its own Brooklyn foreclosure caseMPA Magazine, 12h ago (the report this story comes from)
- [2]HSBC runs out the clock on its own Brooklyn foreclosure caseMortgage Professional America, 7h ago
Background
- [3]Williamsburgh Savings Bank Tower on Wikipedia
- [4]Brooklyn on Grokipedia
- [5]New York court rejects late challenge to Pennymac foreclosure FTMQ Real Estate, 32d ago
Our newsroom writes these reports with the help of software, from the 5 sources listed and nothing else, and checks them against those sources. Facts can still be wrong or move on; the originals are the record. Spotted a mistake? Write to daniel@monsterkong.com.
Related from FTMQ Real Estate
Earlier reports of ours on the same people and subjects.
- Ohio court reverses default foreclosure judgment against incarcerated borrowerMortgage Rates, 6d ago
- Ohio court blocks Deutsche Bank foreclosure over inconsistent note documentationMortgage Rates, 3d ago
- New York court rejects late challenge to Pennymac foreclosureMortgage Rates, 32d ago
- Cushman and Wakefield and New York City named in 52 million dollar suitCommercial Property, 25d ago
- New York Fed data shows U.S. foreclosure crisis failed to materializeTop Stories, 6d ago
More in Mortgage Rates
- Mortgage application fraud risk rises as purchase loans dominate market4h ago
- Older homeowners prioritize aging in place despite rising housing costs1d ago
- Commercial loan renewals face pressure as cap rates double1d ago
- Office development break even point remains years away in US markets1d ago
- Mortgage brokers face potential shift in state regulatory priorities following elections1d ago
- US sales of previously owned homes sink to 16 year low2d ago
Get the day in one email
Reports like this one, the top news of the last 24 hours, every morning. Free, one email a day; readers can comment under every report.
By signing up you agree to our terms and privacy policy. Unsubscribe any time.

Comments
Loading
Join the conversation
Comments are open to readers of our daily email: the top news of the last 24 hours, every morning, free. Sign up and the comment box opens.
Already on the list? Enter the same address and we will send a sign-in link.
By signing up you agree to our terms and privacy policy. Unsubscribe any time.